Dear manarch,

Always a pleasure! Your thorough analysis adds layers to this already complex discussion. Thank you for the in-depth exposition.

Liminal Soup & Neuroscience: Indeed, the essence of what you've called "mystical liminal soup" does find resonance in the scientific realm, specifically neuroscience and psychopharmacology. But let's not forget: science and spirituality are just two languages describing the same indescribable reality. Science offers objectivity, while spirituality provides a deeply personal narrative. They both illuminate aspects of the greater truth but neither holds a monopoly on it. Sure, neuroscience can't give us the qualitative dimension of a spiritual experience. But hey, it's trying, and it's putting some pretty convincing data on the table. That's not to undermine spirituality, but to give it a frame of reference we can all talk about without needing a translator who speaks ‘Guru.’

Woo-Woo and Reality: Your point on the "woo-woo basket" and subjectivity is well taken. I'm not claiming my experience should serve as a universal truth. Rather, it offers a perspective that aligns with ancient wisdom as well as emerging scientific inquiry. Subjective? Absolutely. Dismissible? That's up to individual interpretation. The problem with any spiritual conversation is that it's like trying to describe a dream upon waking. No matter how vivid it was, the essence always seems to slip through your fingers. But we try, because that's how we grow, right?

Advaita & Metaphysics: Your breakdown of Advaita and the concept of Brahman is detailed and accurate. However, I would argue that while these ideas may sound far-fetched to a modern mind, they are not entirely unattainable experiences. The concept of Brahman doesn't negate personal experience; it transcends it. So while Brahman might be "ineffable," our attempts to express it aren't futile. They're like the ol' finger pointing to the moon, not the moon itself.

Simplicity in Complexity: Finally, you bring up an essential point about relatability and simplicity. Yes, life's complex. So is understanding the self. But the basics? Be kind, give more, and I'll add, never assume you know it all. Even if you've got a ton ancient texts under your belt. While these deep dives are enriching, the essence can indeed be simple: showing kindness, being considerate, and as you amusingly added, wearing sunscreen. However, these simple acts are often the most profound. They may not explain the intricacies of existence, but they make the journey worthwhile.

I appreciate the time you took to dissect these ideas. Let's continue to challenge, debate, and delve into the unknown. After all, the quest for understanding is a journey without a final destination.

Kind regards.